On Sunday, Nov. 15, following a potluck lunch, members had a first congregational conversation with Eileen Lindner. She is the consultant hired jointly by the Hopewell and Pennington Presbyterian Churches (HPC and PPC) to assist us in exploring a potential merger. This meeting was a time to meet Eileen, learn more about the process, ask questions, and share thoughts about the benefits, downsides, and scary parts of this possible future.
Pastor Beth Scibienski began the meeting by providing some basic background about Pennington Presbyterian Church.
Congregation size: Currently about twice the HPC congregation
Demographics: Similar to HPC
Finances: Most tithes and offerings come from oldest members
Staff: Larger than HPC's
PPC website: https://pennpres.org/
PPC's discernment process:
Started 3 years ago, prompted by the extensive $2.6 M repairs needed to their sanctuary building
Their focus for future is on people and mission, not buildings
About ready to release a Request For Proposal (RFP) to explore repurposing of their buildings
Options they have considered (the first two have been eliminated):
1. Sharing space at another Pennington church
2. Moving to a non-church space in Pennington area
3. Merging with another Presbyterian congregation (most suitable option)
Eileen Lindner introduced herself as a religious sociologist affiliated with the Presbyterian Foundation. She is highly experienced in working with churches considering mergers, closings, and finding a new course. She explained:
PPC has building issues. It's about money.
HPC has a declining membership. It's about timing.
The issues of both churches will be ongoing within a fairly short timescale.
In her opinion, both congregations are healthier right now than other congregations she has worked with, at the outset of their explorations.
HPC's willingness to discuss & meet is a faithful response to PPC reaching out.
Eileen went on to describe the process she will be following with the two churches.
A Merger Exploration Team (MET) will be formed, with equal parts from each congregation plus Eileen.
It might be at most 5 members from each congregation.
Each person will have responsibility to the MET as well as to their own congregation.
Discussions are meant to be very transparent.
Sequence for MET:
A -- Through a series of conversations, get familiar with both congregations' history, status, programs, population, and reach.
B -- Discuss with both congregations their mission and vision, looking for common values.
C -- Assess the resources of each and how they might contribute to a new congregation. Name the non-negotiables. Vision about what the new congregation could do that continues the mission of each, and what entirely new things it could do. Begin taking steps toward a merger, if that seems indicated.
A PCUSA church is a wholly owned subsidiary of the Presbyterian Church USA. When 2 of its churches merge, both are discontinued, and a completely new entity comes into being.
HPC members in attendance were then invited to ask questions.
What is the current state of play?
The two sessions are exploring possible benefits and deal breakers. A Merge Exploration Team is being formed.
How long is the process?
Discerning a good match for becoming a merged congregation takes 1.5 to 2 years to come to fruition.
Will Presbytery be involved, to monitor or control the exploration?
Eileen will ensure that the MET's process is transparent and orderly and will keep the Presbytery of the Coastlands informed.
How did this merge conversation begin, between the two churches?
Each church Session has been regularly discussing its issue (PPC - building deterioration; HPC - membership decline) over the past 2 to 3 yrs. About a year ago, PPC approached HPC about discussing a possible merger. The 2 Sessions have met twice since then.
Is there some timing urgency for PPC to resolve its situation?
There is urgency on some of the building issues.
Judging the urgency depends on a church's discernment of its calling, not on the status of its property or population.
Could HPC give some money to PPC from the Sharipen Fund?
Yes, that could be an option. HPC would still need to address its membership decline.
What happens to the staff when 2 churches merge?
Decisions would be made jointly about staff needed for the new church entity.
What should HPC and PPC be doing while the MET discussions progress?
Pray, separately and together. Communicate openly. Engage in joint fellowship, worship, and mission activities.
Eileen then asked members to volunteer their thoughts on might be good, bad, or scary about merging. These ideas were shared.
Possible Benefits:
More people being and doing church together
Broader welcome; more kids, younger adults, families
New friends
Larger choirs
HPC less dependent on Sharipen Fund for covering church operating budget
New ideas /programming
Bible studies
Greater pool of volunteers for outreach actions
Possible Downsides:
May lose staff
May lose members from each congregation
Scary Possibilities:
Having a new congregation
Merging, and finding the result is unsuccessful in some way we can’t know now
Eileen closed the meeting with a prayer asking God to guide and care for the process, the MET, and both congregations.